Ad – This comparison contains affiliate links marked [£]. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our rankings, and we include software that pays us nothing. How we make money
QuickBooks, Xero and Sage between them cover most of the UK small-business accounting market, and all three are recognised by HMRC for Making Tax Digital (MTD) for VAT, MTD for Income Tax and payroll. So the question is not whether they work, but which one costs less and fits better for a business like yours.
We compared the three on the things that change the bill and the workload: plan prices after the introductory offer, what you get on the cheapest plan, payroll costs, user limits and how each handles sole traders under MTD for Income Tax. Prices were checked on each vendor’s UK site on 18 November 2026 and exclude VAT.
The short answer
Choose Xero if you want room to grow
Best all-rounder for limited companies and growing teams, with payroll for up to ten people built into the higher plans and a large app marketplace.
Choose Sage if you are VAT-registered with a few staff
The cheapest way to get VAT returns and payroll together: Sage Accounting Start includes one employee, and there is a free plan for non-VAT-registered sole traders.
Choose QuickBooks if you are a sole trader or want flexible payroll
Sole Trader Plus is a low-cost plan built for Self Assessment and MTD for Income Tax, and QuickBooks Payroll handles weekly and four-weekly pay.
Side-by-side comparison
| Xero | QuickBooks Online | Sage Accounting | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plans (regular, ex VAT, as of November 2026) | Ignite £18, Grow £39, Comprehensive £55, Ultimate £70 | From £10 (sole traders) and from £16.60 (limited companies); see Intuit’s UK pricing page for current Essentials, Plus and Advanced regular prices | Sole Trader Free £0, Sole Trader £7, Start £20, Standard £43, Plus £59 |
| Current new-customer offer | 90% off for 6 months, or one month free | 30-day free trial, or a discount instead of the trial | 90% off for 10 months on Start, Standard and Plus |
| Cheapest plan with VAT returns | Ignite (£18) | Simple Start (limited-company plans from £16.60 as of November 2026) | Start (£20) |
| Sole trader plan for MTD for Income Tax | Ignite (all plans are MTD for Income Tax ready) | Sole Trader Plus | Sole Trader Free and Sole Trader |
| Payroll | Ignite £1.50 per person; Grow 1, Comprehensive 5, Ultimate 10 included; extra people £1.50, or £1 on Ultimate | Paid add-on: Core £5 a month + £1.50 per active employee | Start and Standard 1 included, Plus 5; then £1.85 per employee |
| Users | Not charged per user; expenses and projects users vary by plan | 1 (Sole Trader Plus, Simple Start), 3, 5, 25 | 1 (Start), 3 (Standard), unlimited (Plus) |
| CIS | Calculations on every plan; CIS returns an add-on (£5 a month) | Calculate and submit CIS on every plan, including Sole Trader Plus | Start: CIS as a subcontractor only; Standard or Plus for contractor CIS and monthly CIS300 returns |
| Multi-currency | From Comprehensive | From Essentials | Plus only |
Price: what you actually pay
All three lead with big introductory discounts, which makes headline prices misleading. Here is what three typical businesses would pay per month once the offers end.
A non-VAT-registered sole trader in MTD for Income Tax. Sage’s Sole Trader Free plan costs nothing and its paid Sole Trader plan is £7. QuickBooks sole-trader plans start at £10 a month ex VAT (as of November 2026), which is the Sole Trader Plus tier. Xero’s cheapest plan, Ignite, is £18 and limits you to 20 invoices and 10 bills a month. On price alone, Sage wins for the simplest books.
A VAT-registered limited company with a director and two employees, one user. Sage Start costs £20 plus two extra employees at £1.85, so £23.70. QuickBooks limited-company plans start at £16.60 (as of November 2026); plus Payroll Core that is £16.60 + £5 + 3 × £1.50 = £26.10. Xero Grow is £39 plus two extra people at £1.50, so £42. Sage is the cheapest here, and the difference is about £220 a year against Xero.
A growing business with three users and five staff. Sage Standard is £43 plus four extra employees at £1.85, so £50.40. Xero Comprehensive is £55 with payroll for five included. QuickBooks Essentials (3 users) plus Payroll Core would be the current Essentials list price on Intuit’s UK pricing page (https://quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing/), plus £5 + 5 × £1.50. We have not restated that mid-tier list price here, so we have not given a QuickBooks total for this example. At this size Sage and Xero are close, and features should decide.
Sole traders and MTD for Income Tax
Since 6 April 2026, sole traders and landlords with qualifying income over £50,000 must keep digital records and send quarterly updates through compatible software. The threshold drops to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028 (GOV.UK).
All three vendors appear on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder. The differences are in coverage and cost:
- Xero is listed for self-employment, UK property and foreign property income, so it suits landlords with overseas lets.
- QuickBooks is listed for self-employment and UK property income.
- Sage (both the Sole Trader & Landlord products and Accounting from Sage) is listed for self-employment and UK property income, and has a free version.
One correction worth making: QuickBooks’ own MTD page describes quarterly reporting as “replacing the annual Self Assessment tax return”. That is not how HMRC describes it. Under MTD for Income Tax you still submit a tax return through your software by 31 January after the tax year ends; quarterly updates are summaries, not returns. See our Making Tax Digital guide.
VAT
All VAT-registered businesses must use MTD-compatible software for VAT (GOV.UK). Xero lets you submit VAT returns on every plan, including Ignite. QuickBooks starts at Simple Start, because Sole Trader Plus has no VAT submission. Sage starts at Accounting Start; its Sole Trader plans are designed for businesses that are not VAT-registered. QuickBooks and Sage both promote AI checks that flag likely VAT errors before you file.
Payroll
Payroll is where the three differ most.
- Sage includes payroll in all business plans, with built-in HR features such as leave management and self-service payslips. Extra employees are £1.85 a month.
- Xero includes payroll from Grow upwards (1, 5 or 10 people) and charges £1.50 per extra person, or £1 on Ultimate, which is the cheapest per-head rate of the three.
- QuickBooks charges separately. Payroll Core is £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages. It supports weekly, two-weekly, four-weekly and monthly pay and sends pension contributions to NEST automatically. Since June 2026 it bills for every employee marked Active, so keep leavers marked “Not on payroll”.
If payroll matters more to you than accounting, compare dedicated options in our best payroll software guide.
Users and growth
Xero does not charge per user, but its plans limit features such as expenses, projects and payroll by headcount. QuickBooks has hard user caps (1, 3, 5 and 25), so adding a second person to Simple Start means moving up to Essentials. Sage Start is single-user, Standard allows three and Plus is unlimited. For a business that expects to hire, Xero and Sage Plus give the most headroom without a big jump in price.
Ease of use and ecosystem
We have not run a structured hands-on test of all three for this comparison, so we will not score them on ease of use. What we can say from their documentation: Xero and QuickBooks have the largest third-party app marketplaces, which matters if you use e-commerce, job management or receipt apps. Sage’s advantage is that accounting, payroll and HR sit in one subscription. All three have mobile apps with receipt capture and are widely supported by UK accountants, so ask yours which they prefer before you choose.
Xero: pros and cons
Pros: VAT returns on every plan; payroll for up to 10 included on higher plans; cheapest extra-employee rate; covers foreign property income for MTD; no per-user fees.
Cons: Ignite’s invoice and bill limits; the most expensive option for a small VAT-registered company with staff; multi-currency only from £55.
Sage Accounting: pros and cons
Pros: Free and £7 plans for non-VAT sole traders; payroll included in every business plan; cheapest for a small VAT-registered team; UK-based support.
Cons: Start is single-user; multi-currency and inventory only on Plus; receipt capture limited on lower plans.
QuickBooks Online: pros and cons
Pros: Low-cost Sole Trader Plus plan; CIS on every plan; flexible payroll frequencies; strong app ecosystem; 30-day free trial.
Cons: Payroll always extra; hard user caps; no VAT submission on the cheapest plan; mid-tier plan prices are hard to read on Intuit’s main pricing page.
When none of the three is right
The big three are not automatically the best choice. If you are a freelancer or run a one-person company and bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle, FreeAgent is free and includes payroll; we earn nothing from it. If you want the most capable free plan, Zoho Books covers MTD for Income Tax, MTD VAT and Self Assessment filing at no cost. And if you mainly need invoicing and time tracking, FreshBooks is pleasant to use, but it was not on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder on 15 November 2026, so it is not a complete answer for sole traders joining MTD. Our best accounting software round-up covers all of these in detail.
How to decide in five minutes
- If you are not VAT-registered and your books are simple, start with Sage’s free Sole Trader plan or QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus.
- If you are VAT-registered with one to three staff and one user, price Sage Start first.
- If you have several users, expect to hire, or rely on third-party apps, choose Xero.
- If you pay staff weekly or four-weekly and already like QuickBooks, add QuickBooks Payroll.
- Whatever you pick, use the free trial or first discounted month to connect your bank feed and run one real VAT return or pay run before committing.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, QuickBooks, Xero or Sage?
It depends on your business. For a non-VAT-registered sole trader, Sage is cheapest thanks to its free plan. For a small VAT-registered company with a couple of employees, Sage Start with included payroll worked out cheapest in our example. For larger teams the three are close once payroll is added.
Are QuickBooks, Xero and Sage all compatible with Making Tax Digital?
Yes. All three appeared on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder on 15 November 2026 and all can file MTD VAT returns, although QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus and Sage’s Sole Trader plans do not include VAT submission.
Which is best for a limited company?
Xero is our pick for most limited companies because of its payroll, app ecosystem and room to grow. Sage Accounting is the better value choice for a VAT-registered company with only a few staff.
Does Xero, QuickBooks or Sage include payroll?
Sage includes payroll for at least one employee on every business plan. Xero includes it from the Grow plan (and charges £1.50 per person on Ignite, or £1 extra on Ultimate). QuickBooks charges for payroll as an add-on, starting at £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee.
Can I switch between QuickBooks, Xero and Sage?
Yes. All three offer import tools or migration help, and Sage says it will cover the cost of moving two years of data from your current software. Switching is easiest at the end of a VAT quarter or financial year.