How we choose and rank software

Every comparison on BooksCompass follows the same method, so you can see why a product is where it is, and judge for yourself whether our priorities match yours.

1. Compliance comes first

UK small businesses have legal reporting duties, so we check these before anything else:

  • Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. Is the product on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder, and for which income types (self-employment, UK property, foreign property)? Can it submit the year-end tax return as well as quarterly updates?
  • Making Tax Digital for VAT. Can it submit VAT returns to HMRC, and on which plans?
  • Payroll. Is its payroll product on HMRC’s list of recognised payroll software? Does it handle payslips, auto-enrolment and Full Payment Submissions?

A product that is not recognised for something we would expect it to do is clearly flagged, even if it is otherwise good.

2. The real cost

Introductory offers such as “90% off for six months” make headline prices misleading. We:

  • quote the regular monthly price after the offer, excluding VAT, and mention the offer separately
  • include the add-ons a typical small business ends up paying for, such as payroll per employee, extra users and receipt capture
  • work through example businesses (for instance a VAT-registered company with two employees) where it helps
  • show the date we checked prices, and clearly flag anything we could not confirm on the vendor’s own page

3. Fit for UK businesses

We look for UK bank feeds, the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) for builders, support for UK tax years and update periods, and UK-based customer support. We also consider who the product is really built for, which is why our rankings use “best for” labels rather than a single winner.

4. Day-to-day usability

Where we have used a product hands-on, we describe what it is like to set up and use, and say that we tested it. Where we have not, we say so and stick to what the documentation, pricing pages and HMRC lists show. We do not invent test scores.

5. Independence

  • Commission never decides whether a product is included or where it ranks.
  • We include software with no affiliate programme when it is the right answer, such as FreeAgent, BrightPay, Moneysoft and HMRC’s Basic PAYE Tools.
  • Affiliate links are labelled [£] and every commercial article carries a notice at the top. See how we make money.

Our sources

  • Vendors’ UK pricing and feature pages
  • HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder and recognised payroll software list
  • GOV.UK guidance on Making Tax Digital, VAT and payroll

We do not copy other review sites’ scores or wording.

Keeping guides up to date

Software prices and HMRC lists change often. Each article shows when it was last updated and when prices were checked. We aim to recheck our main guides at least every quarter and whenever HMRC changes its rules.

Found something out of date? Email hello@bookscompass.co.uk.