Author: bc_admin

  • QuickBooks vs Xero vs Sage: which is best for your UK business? (2026)

    Updated 18 November 2026 · By The BooksCompass team · Prices and features checked 18 November 2026

    Ad – This comparison contains affiliate links marked [£]. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our rankings, and we include software that pays us nothing. How we make money

    QuickBooks, Xero and Sage between them cover most of the UK small-business accounting market, and all three are recognised by HMRC for Making Tax Digital (MTD) for VAT, MTD for Income Tax and payroll. So the question is not whether they work, but which one costs less and fits better for a business like yours.

    We compared the three on the things that change the bill and the workload: plan prices after the introductory offer, what you get on the cheapest plan, payroll costs, user limits and how each handles sole traders under MTD for Income Tax. Prices were checked on each vendor’s UK site on 18 November 2026 and exclude VAT.

    The short answer

    Choose Xero if you want room to grow

    Best all-rounder for limited companies and growing teams, with payroll for up to ten people built into the higher plans and a large app marketplace.

    Choose Sage if you are VAT-registered with a few staff

    The cheapest way to get VAT returns and payroll together: Sage Accounting Start includes one employee, and there is a free plan for non-VAT-registered sole traders.

    Choose QuickBooks if you are a sole trader or want flexible payroll

    Sole Trader Plus is a low-cost plan built for Self Assessment and MTD for Income Tax, and QuickBooks Payroll handles weekly and four-weekly pay.

    Side-by-side comparison

    XeroQuickBooks OnlineSage Accounting
    Plans (regular, ex VAT, as of November 2026)Ignite £18, Grow £39, Comprehensive £55, Ultimate £70From £10 (sole traders) and from £16.60 (limited companies); see Intuit’s UK pricing page for current Essentials, Plus and Advanced regular pricesSole Trader Free £0, Sole Trader £7, Start £20, Standard £43, Plus £59
    Current new-customer offer90% off for 6 months, or one month free30-day free trial, or a discount instead of the trial90% off for 10 months on Start, Standard and Plus
    Cheapest plan with VAT returnsIgnite (£18)Simple Start (limited-company plans from £16.60 as of November 2026)Start (£20)
    Sole trader plan for MTD for Income TaxIgnite (all plans are MTD for Income Tax ready)Sole Trader PlusSole Trader Free and Sole Trader
    PayrollIgnite £1.50 per person; Grow 1, Comprehensive 5, Ultimate 10 included; extra people £1.50, or £1 on UltimatePaid add-on: Core £5 a month + £1.50 per active employeeStart and Standard 1 included, Plus 5; then £1.85 per employee
    UsersNot charged per user; expenses and projects users vary by plan1 (Sole Trader Plus, Simple Start), 3, 5, 251 (Start), 3 (Standard), unlimited (Plus)
    CISCalculations on every plan; CIS returns an add-on (£5 a month)Calculate and submit CIS on every plan, including Sole Trader PlusStart: CIS as a subcontractor only; Standard or Plus for contractor CIS and monthly CIS300 returns
    Multi-currencyFrom ComprehensiveFrom EssentialsPlus only

    Price: what you actually pay

    All three lead with big introductory discounts, which makes headline prices misleading. Here is what three typical businesses would pay per month once the offers end.

    A non-VAT-registered sole trader in MTD for Income Tax. Sage’s Sole Trader Free plan costs nothing and its paid Sole Trader plan is £7. QuickBooks sole-trader plans start at £10 a month ex VAT (as of November 2026), which is the Sole Trader Plus tier. Xero’s cheapest plan, Ignite, is £18 and limits you to 20 invoices and 10 bills a month. On price alone, Sage wins for the simplest books.

    A VAT-registered limited company with a director and two employees, one user. Sage Start costs £20 plus two extra employees at £1.85, so £23.70. QuickBooks limited-company plans start at £16.60 (as of November 2026); plus Payroll Core that is £16.60 + £5 + 3 × £1.50 = £26.10. Xero Grow is £39 plus two extra people at £1.50, so £42. Sage is the cheapest here, and the difference is about £220 a year against Xero.

    A growing business with three users and five staff. Sage Standard is £43 plus four extra employees at £1.85, so £50.40. Xero Comprehensive is £55 with payroll for five included. QuickBooks Essentials (3 users) plus Payroll Core would be the current Essentials list price on Intuit’s UK pricing page (https://quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing/), plus £5 + 5 × £1.50. We have not restated that mid-tier list price here, so we have not given a QuickBooks total for this example. At this size Sage and Xero are close, and features should decide.

    Sole traders and MTD for Income Tax

    Since 6 April 2026, sole traders and landlords with qualifying income over £50,000 must keep digital records and send quarterly updates through compatible software. The threshold drops to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028 (GOV.UK).

    All three vendors appear on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder. The differences are in coverage and cost:

    • Xero is listed for self-employment, UK property and foreign property income, so it suits landlords with overseas lets.
    • QuickBooks is listed for self-employment and UK property income.
    • Sage (both the Sole Trader & Landlord products and Accounting from Sage) is listed for self-employment and UK property income, and has a free version.

    One correction worth making: QuickBooks’ own MTD page describes quarterly reporting as “replacing the annual Self Assessment tax return”. That is not how HMRC describes it. Under MTD for Income Tax you still submit a tax return through your software by 31 January after the tax year ends; quarterly updates are summaries, not returns. See our Making Tax Digital guide.

    VAT

    All VAT-registered businesses must use MTD-compatible software for VAT (GOV.UK). Xero lets you submit VAT returns on every plan, including Ignite. QuickBooks starts at Simple Start, because Sole Trader Plus has no VAT submission. Sage starts at Accounting Start; its Sole Trader plans are designed for businesses that are not VAT-registered. QuickBooks and Sage both promote AI checks that flag likely VAT errors before you file.

    Payroll

    Payroll is where the three differ most.

    • Sage includes payroll in all business plans, with built-in HR features such as leave management and self-service payslips. Extra employees are £1.85 a month.
    • Xero includes payroll from Grow upwards (1, 5 or 10 people) and charges £1.50 per extra person, or £1 on Ultimate, which is the cheapest per-head rate of the three.
    • QuickBooks charges separately. Payroll Core is £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages. It supports weekly, two-weekly, four-weekly and monthly pay and sends pension contributions to NEST automatically. Since June 2026 it bills for every employee marked Active, so keep leavers marked “Not on payroll”.

    If payroll matters more to you than accounting, compare dedicated options in our best payroll software guide.

    Users and growth

    Xero does not charge per user, but its plans limit features such as expenses, projects and payroll by headcount. QuickBooks has hard user caps (1, 3, 5 and 25), so adding a second person to Simple Start means moving up to Essentials. Sage Start is single-user, Standard allows three and Plus is unlimited. For a business that expects to hire, Xero and Sage Plus give the most headroom without a big jump in price.

    Ease of use and ecosystem

    We have not run a structured hands-on test of all three for this comparison, so we will not score them on ease of use. What we can say from their documentation: Xero and QuickBooks have the largest third-party app marketplaces, which matters if you use e-commerce, job management or receipt apps. Sage’s advantage is that accounting, payroll and HR sit in one subscription. All three have mobile apps with receipt capture and are widely supported by UK accountants, so ask yours which they prefer before you choose.

    Xero: pros and cons

    Pros: VAT returns on every plan; payroll for up to 10 included on higher plans; cheapest extra-employee rate; covers foreign property income for MTD; no per-user fees.

    Cons: Ignite’s invoice and bill limits; the most expensive option for a small VAT-registered company with staff; multi-currency only from £55.

    Sage Accounting: pros and cons

    Pros: Free and £7 plans for non-VAT sole traders; payroll included in every business plan; cheapest for a small VAT-registered team; UK-based support.

    Cons: Start is single-user; multi-currency and inventory only on Plus; receipt capture limited on lower plans.

    QuickBooks Online: pros and cons

    Pros: Low-cost Sole Trader Plus plan; CIS on every plan; flexible payroll frequencies; strong app ecosystem; 30-day free trial.

    Cons: Payroll always extra; hard user caps; no VAT submission on the cheapest plan; mid-tier plan prices are hard to read on Intuit’s main pricing page.

    When none of the three is right

    The big three are not automatically the best choice. If you are a freelancer or run a one-person company and bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle, FreeAgent is free and includes payroll; we earn nothing from it. If you want the most capable free plan, Zoho Books covers MTD for Income Tax, MTD VAT and Self Assessment filing at no cost. And if you mainly need invoicing and time tracking, FreshBooks is pleasant to use, but it was not on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder on 15 November 2026, so it is not a complete answer for sole traders joining MTD. Our best accounting software round-up covers all of these in detail.

    How to decide in five minutes

    1. If you are not VAT-registered and your books are simple, start with Sage’s free Sole Trader plan or QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus.
    2. If you are VAT-registered with one to three staff and one user, price Sage Start first.
    3. If you have several users, expect to hire, or rely on third-party apps, choose Xero.
    4. If you pay staff weekly or four-weekly and already like QuickBooks, add QuickBooks Payroll.
    5. Whatever you pick, use the free trial or first discounted month to connect your bank feed and run one real VAT return or pay run before committing.

    Frequently asked questions

    Which is cheaper, QuickBooks, Xero or Sage?

    It depends on your business. For a non-VAT-registered sole trader, Sage is cheapest thanks to its free plan. For a small VAT-registered company with a couple of employees, Sage Start with included payroll worked out cheapest in our example. For larger teams the three are close once payroll is added.

    Are QuickBooks, Xero and Sage all compatible with Making Tax Digital?

    Yes. All three appeared on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder on 15 November 2026 and all can file MTD VAT returns, although QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus and Sage’s Sole Trader plans do not include VAT submission.

    Which is best for a limited company?

    Xero is our pick for most limited companies because of its payroll, app ecosystem and room to grow. Sage Accounting is the better value choice for a VAT-registered company with only a few staff.

    Does Xero, QuickBooks or Sage include payroll?

    Sage includes payroll for at least one employee on every business plan. Xero includes it from the Grow plan (and charges £1.50 per person on Ignite, or £1 extra on Ultimate). QuickBooks charges for payroll as an add-on, starting at £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee.

    Can I switch between QuickBooks, Xero and Sage?

    Yes. All three offer import tools or migration help, and Sage says it will cover the cost of moving two years of data from your current software. Switching is easiest at the end of a VAT quarter or financial year.

    About the author

    The BooksCompass team researches UK accounting, payroll and bookkeeping software for sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. We check prices and features against vendor pages and HMRC guidance on GOV.UK, and we say when something has not been tested hands-on. How we choose · hello@bookscompass.co.uk

  • Making Tax Digital for Income Tax: a plain-English guide for sole traders and landlords

    Updated 15 November 2026 · By The BooksCompass team · Prices and features checked 15 November 2026

    Some links in this guide are affiliate links, marked [£]. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How we make money

    Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax is the biggest change to Self Assessment in a generation. Instead of totting up a year’s figures once a year, sole traders and landlords keep digital records and send HMRC a short summary every three months, then finish the year with a tax return filed from their software.

    It became mandatory on 6 April 2026 for those with the highest incomes and is being extended in two more stages. This guide explains who it applies to, when, what you have to do and what happens if you miss a deadline. Everything here was checked against GOV.UK on 15 November 2026, and we link to the relevant HMRC guidance throughout. It is general information, not tax advice; if your situation is complicated, speak to an accountant.

    Who has to use MTD for Income Tax

    You need to use MTD for Income Tax if all of these apply (GOV.UK):

    • you are a sole trader or a landlord registered for Self Assessment
    • you get income from self-employment, property, or both
    • your qualifying income is above the threshold for the relevant tax year

    Qualifying income is your combined gross income from self-employment and property, before expenses and tax. It is turnover, not profit. A plumber with £35,000 of sales and £15,000 of costs has qualifying income of £35,000, not £20,000. Employment income, pensions, dividends and savings interest do not count towards the threshold.

    Partnerships do not have to use MTD for Income Tax yet. HMRC says it will set out a timeline later.

    When you have to start

    If your qualifying income was overIn the tax yearYou must use MTD for Income Tax from
    £50,0002024 to 20256 April 2026
    £30,0002025 to 20266 April 2027
    £20,0002026 to 20276 April 2028

    Source: GOV.UK, Find out if and when you need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, last updated 26 March 2026.

    HMRC checks your Self Assessment return each year and writes to you if you are over the threshold. But if no letter arrives, it is still your responsibility to check and sign up. HMRC has also said that from September 2026 it began signing up people who should already be using MTD for the 2026 to 2027 tax year but had not done so (GOV.UK).

    If you are in the April 2027 group, HMRC estimates that around 1,077,000 more sole traders and landlords will join you (GOV.UK). Now is a good time to choose software, because you can sign up early and practise.

    What you have to do

    Once you are in MTD for Income Tax, there are three jobs (GOV.UK):

    1. Keep digital records of your self-employment and property income and expenses in compatible software, or in spreadsheets linked to bridging software.
    2. Send a quarterly update to HMRC every three months for each self-employment and property business you have.
    3. Submit your tax return through your software by 31 January after the end of the tax year, adding any other income such as employment, dividends or savings interest.

    Quarterly updates are summaries, not tax returns. Your software adds up your records by category; you do not need to make accounting or tax adjustments first, and HMRC does not see individual receipts or invoices. Each update covers the tax year so far, so errors can be corrected in the next one. If you had no income or expenses in a period, you still have to send an update (GOV.UK).

    After each update, you can see an estimate of your tax bill so far in your software and your HMRC online account, which is one genuine benefit of the new system.

    Quarterly update deadlines

    Most people use standard update periods, which follow the tax year. If your accounts run from 1 April to 31 March, you can choose calendar update periods instead, but you must choose before sending your first update. The deadlines are the same either way.

    Standard update periodCalendar update periodDeadline
    6 April to 5 July1 April to 30 June7 August
    6 April to 5 October1 April to 30 September7 November
    6 April to 5 January1 April to 31 December7 February
    6 April to 5 April1 April to 31 March7 May (following tax year)

    Source: GOV.UK, Send quarterly updates.

    If you start in April 2027, your first year would look like this: digital records from 6 April 2027 (or 1 April with calendar periods), updates by 7 August 2027, 7 November 2027, 7 February 2028 and 7 May 2028, and your first MTD tax return by 31 January 2029. You still file your 2025 to 2026 and 2026 to 2027 returns in the usual way.

    Penalties

    MTD for Income Tax brings a new penalty system from the tax year you join (GOV.UK):

    • Late submissions earn points. You get one point for each missed deadline. At 4 points you pay a £200 penalty, and another £200 for each further missed deadline. Points below the threshold expire after 24 months.
    • No points for late quarterly updates in 2026 to 2027. HMRC is not applying points for late quarterly updates during the first year. Points still apply to a late tax return, and you must send all your quarterly updates before you can file the return.
    • Late payment penalties depend on how late you pay. For 2026 to 2027, paying 16 to 30 days late costs 3% of the tax owed at day 15; at 31 days or more, a further 3% plus 10% a year on the outstanding amount. For 2027 to 2028, the percentages rise to 4%. In your first year you have 30 days before penalties begin; after that it is 15 days.

    Exemptions

    Some people do not have to use MTD for Income Tax (GOV.UK). Automatic exemptions include:

    • qualifying income of £20,000 or less
    • not having a National Insurance number before the start of the tax year
    • trusts, non-resident companies and personal representatives of someone who has died
    • some people who made specific claims on their 2024 to 2025 return, such as averaging relief or qualifying care relief, who are exempt until April 2027 at the earliest

    You can also apply for an exemption if you are digitally excluded, meaning it is not reasonable for you to use software, for example because of age, disability or location. If you are exempt, you keep filing a normal Self Assessment return.

    Choosing software

    HMRC does not sell MTD software, so you need a commercial product. Use HMRC’s software finder to filter by your income types (self-employment, UK property, foreign property) and whether you want a free version.

    There are two kinds:

    • Software that creates digital records, such as Xero, QuickBooks, Sage, FreeAgent and Zoho Books. It links to your bank, captures receipts and usually handles both quarterly updates and the tax return.
    • Bridging software, which connects existing spreadsheets to HMRC. It suits people happy with their spreadsheets, but check it can submit the tax return as well as quarterly updates.

    You can use more than one product, for example one for your trade and another for a rental property, but only one product for each separate submission. On 15 November 2026 HMRC’s finder included free versions from Zoho, Sage, Clear Books, Coconut and Pandle, and FreeAgent is free with NatWest, RBS or Mettle business accounts. Our best accounting software guide compares the main options, or see QuickBooks vs Xero vs Sage. A few to start with:

    What about VAT?

    MTD for VAT is separate and already applies to all VAT-registered businesses, which HMRC has signed up automatically (GOV.UK). You must register for VAT if your taxable turnover goes over £90,000 in a rolling 12 months (GOV.UK). If you are both VAT-registered and in MTD for Income Tax, choose software that does both; penalty points for each are kept separately.

    Your MTD checklist

    1. Work out your qualifying income for 2025 to 2026 (gross self-employment plus property income).
    2. Use HMRC’s checker to confirm if and when you need to start, or whether you are exempt.
    3. Choose software that covers all your income types and that your accountant supports.
    4. Sign up on GOV.UK. You must be registered for Self Assessment and have filed a return in the last two years.
    5. Set your update period (standard or calendar) in your software before the first update.
    6. Diary the four deadlines: 7 August, 7 November, 7 February and 7 May, plus 31 January for the return.

    Frequently asked questions

    When does Making Tax Digital for Income Tax start?

    It started on 6 April 2026 for sole traders and landlords with qualifying income over £50,000 in 2024 to 2025. It applies from 6 April 2027 if your qualifying income was over £30,000 in 2025 to 2026, and from 6 April 2028 if it was over £20,000 in 2026 to 2027.

    Is the MTD threshold based on profit or turnover?

    Turnover. Qualifying income is your combined gross income from self-employment and property before expenses and tax. Other income such as employment, pensions or dividends does not count towards the threshold.

    Do I still need to file a Self Assessment tax return under MTD?

    Yes. Quarterly updates are summaries, not tax returns. You still submit a tax return, through your MTD software, by 31 January after the end of the tax year.

    What happens if I miss a quarterly update?

    For the 2026 to 2027 tax year HMRC is not giving penalty points for late quarterly updates, but you must send them all before filing your return. After that, each missed deadline earns a point and reaching 4 points triggers a £200 penalty.

    Can I keep using spreadsheets for MTD for Income Tax?

    Yes, if you use bridging software that connects your spreadsheets to HMRC. Check that it can send quarterly updates and submit your tax return, or pair it with another product that can.

    Do partnerships need to use MTD for Income Tax?

    Not yet. Partnerships are currently automatically exempt, and HMRC has said it will set out a timeline for them later.

    About the author

    The BooksCompass team researches UK accounting, payroll and bookkeeping software for sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. We check prices and features against vendor pages and HMRC guidance on GOV.UK, and we say when something has not been tested hands-on. How we choose · hello@bookscompass.co.uk

  • Best payroll software for UK small businesses (2026)

    Updated 18 November 2026 · By The BooksCompass team · Prices and features checked 18 November 2026

    Ad – This comparison contains affiliate links marked [£]. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our rankings, and we include software that pays us nothing. How we make money

    If you employ anyone in the UK, including paying yourself a salary as a company director, you need payroll software that reports PAYE to HMRC in real time, unless you are exempt (GOV.UK). The sensible starting point is HMRC’s own list of recognised payroll software, which was last updated on 12 November 2026 (GOV.UK). Every product in this guide is on that list.

    HMRC is careful to say it cannot recommend one product over another. We can, so below we narrow a list of around 150 suppliers down to the handful that make most sense for sole-trader employers, small limited companies and micro businesses. Prices were checked on vendors’ UK pages on 18 November 2026 and exclude VAT unless stated.

    Our picks at a glance

    Best dedicated payroll for small employers: BrightPay

    Specialist payroll software with per-employee pricing and every feature included. We earn nothing from BrightPay.

    Best accounting and payroll in one: Sage Accounting

    Payroll for one employee is included in every Sage Accounting business plan (five on Plus), then £1.85 per employee a month.

    Best if you already use Xero: Xero Payroll

    Built into Xero’s Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate plans, or £1.50 per person on Ignite.

    Best free option for under 10 employees: HMRC Basic PAYE Tools

    Free from HMRC itself, with no subscription. Basic, but it does the legal minimum.

    Comparison table

    ProductStarting price (ex VAT/month)Free trialEmployees/users includedMTD-readyHMRC-recognisedBest for
    BrightPay CloudFrom £8.25 a month ex VAT (1 employer, up to 3 employees; as of November 2026), or £84 a year (£7/month billed annually). Then banded per employee; extra employers add a flat fee. Annual billing is discounted. Use Bright’s calculator for other counts.Yes — free trial, full access (vendor)Base monthly price covers 1 employer with up to 3 employees; then per-employee bands. Starters and leavers counted. Up to 300 employees per employer (vendor).Yes — RTI (FPS) and auto-enrolment; CIS via BrightCISYes — BrightPay is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Specialist payroll for small employers, bookkeepers and bureaus
    Sage Accounting (payroll included)From £20 a month for Start (as of November 2026), which includes payroll for 1 employee; Standard £43 (1 included); Plus £59 (5 included); then £1.85 per extra employee90% off for 10 months on Start, Standard and Plus; Sole Trader plans are not the payroll business plans1 employee on Start and Standard; 5 on PlusYes — RTI / PAYE and National Insurance calculations, employee payslips and salary payments (vendor)Yes — Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)VAT-registered businesses that want accounting and payroll in one subscription
    Sage Payroll (standalone)From £12 a month (Payroll Essentials) as of November 2026; Standard and Premium also offered. Extra employees from £2.40 / £4.40 / £6.40 a month respectively, with volume discounts, up to 150 employees. 90% off for 10 months is currently advertised (then the regular price).Promotional 90% off for 10 months (vendor). Cancel-anytime rolling subscription.5 employees included on every planYes — RTI submissions, auto-enrolment / workplace pensions, payslips (vendor)Yes — Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Standalone cloud payroll and HR for businesses that do not want Sage Accounting
    Xero PayrollIgnite £18 + £1.50 per person; or included in Grow £39 (1 person), Comprehensive £55 (5), Ultimate £70 (10). Extra people £1.50 a month, or £1 on Ultimate (as of November 2026).90% off for 6 months for new customers, or one month free (base Xero plan)1 / 5 / 10 people included on Grow / Comprehensive / Ultimate; none included on IgniteYes — payroll inside Xero with RTI (vendor)Yes — Xero Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Existing Xero users and businesses already choosing Xero for accounting
    QuickBooks PayrollAdd-on to QuickBooks Online (Simple Start and above, not Sole Trader Plus). Core: £5 a month + £1.50 per active employee. Premium: £10 + £2. Elite: £15 + £3. Plus a QuickBooks plan (limited-company plans from £16.60 a month as of November 2026).30-day free trial on QuickBooks Online (or a discount instead of the trial)No employees included in the Core base fee; you pay per employee marked Active at the start of the billing monthYes — automatic FPS filing, auto-enrolment and NEST submissions on Core (vendor)Yes — QuickBooks is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)QuickBooks users; weekly or four-weekly pay
    FreeAgentIncluded with the accounting plan: from £19 a month (sole trader) or £33 (limited company), or free with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or qualifying Mettle use (as of November 2026)30-day free trial; 50% off for the first 6 months (or first year if annual)Payroll included; FreeAgent says you can pay as many employees as you need. Monthly payroll only.Yes — files PAYE and National Insurance to HMRC (vendor)Yes — FreeAgent is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026) and on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026)Directors of one-person companies and very small teams paid monthly
    Moneysoft Payroll Manager£95 a year ex VAT for 1 employer with up to 20 employees (about £7.92 a month). £190 a year ex VAT for multiple employers, up to 100 employees each; £285 a year ex VAT for up to 250 (as of November 2026).Not stated on the pricing pagePayroll Manager 20: 1 employer, up to 20 employees including leavers in the tax yearYes — RTI filing online (vendor; internet required)Yes — Moneysoft Payroll Manager is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Bookkeepers and cost-conscious employers happy with Windows 11 desktop software
    HMRC Basic PAYE ToolsFreeNot applicable — free download from GOV.UKFewer than 10 employeesRTI (FPS and EPS) yes. Can create payslips (save as PDF). Does not support auto-enrolment or calculate pension contributions.Yes — listed under free payroll software on HMRC’s recognised list (updated 12 November 2026)Employers with fewer than 10 staff who can handle pensions separately

    What your payroll software must do

    Before comparing features, it helps to be clear on the legal basics. As an employer you must register with HMRC, report pay and deductions to HMRC on or before each payday in a Full Payment Submission (FPS), produce payslips for each employee, and send an Employer Payment Summary (EPS) in any tax month when you paid nobody (GOV.UK: running payroll). You also have workplace pension (auto-enrolment) duties for eligible staff.

    GOV.UK suggests checking whether software can:

    • produce payslips
    • record pension deductions and make pension payments
    • pay different people over different periods (for example weekly and monthly)
    • send an Employer Payment Summary (EPS) or Earlier Year Update (EYU)

    Not every recognised product does all of these, especially the free ones.

    How we chose

    We only considered products on HMRC’s recognised list on 15 November 2026. From there we favoured software that a business with roughly 1 to 25 employees can set up without an accountant, that handles auto-enrolment, and that has transparent UK pricing. We have not run payroll in every product ourselves; our assessments are based on vendor documentation, pricing pages and HMRC’s lists. See how we choose.

    1. BrightPay: best dedicated payroll for small employers

    BrightPay, from Bright Software Group, is one of the most popular specialist payroll products among UK accountants and bureaus, and it works just as well for a single employer. It is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list. It handles RTI submissions, auto-enrolment, statutory payments and employee self-service. From the 2026/27 tax year BrightPay is cloud-only: Bright’s UK pricing FAQ says the desktop version no longer receives updates, support or legislative compliance.

    Price: BrightPay Cloud prices per employee, banded by your highest recorded number of employers and employees, with monthly or annual billing and every feature included. Annual billing is discounted. There is a free trial. As of November 2026, Bright’s official UK calculator starts at £8.25 a month ex VAT for one employer with up to three employees, or £84 a year ex VAT (£7.00 a month when billed annually). From four employees, a per-employee rate applies and falls as the headcount band rises; extra employers add a flat fee. Use Bright’s pricing calculator (https://brightsg.com/brightpay-cloud-payroll-software/#pricing) for your own counts.

    BrightPay has no public affiliate programme, so we earn nothing if you choose it.

    Pros

    • Payroll specialist with full auto-enrolment and employee self-service
    • Every feature included in per-employee pricing
    • Widely supported by UK accountants

    Cons

    • Separate from your accounting software, so you will need an integration or journal export
    • Pricing is banded, so the monthly bill rises with your highest recorded employer and employee counts

    2. Sage Accounting: best accounting and payroll in one

    Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s list, and Sage now includes payroll in every Sage Accounting business plan: one employee on Start (£20 a month) and Standard (£43), five on Plus (£59), then £1.85 per employee a month. It covers RTI, automatic tax and National Insurance calculations, employee self-service payslips, leave management and salary payments, and Sage Copilot flags pay that looks unusual. Sage 50 Payroll, the desktop product, is also on HMRC’s list for larger or more traditional set-ups.

    Pros

    • No separate payroll subscription for very small teams
    • Payroll and accounting in one place, so journals post automatically
    • UK-based support

    Cons

    • Per-employee charges add up beyond a handful of staff
    • Shift scheduling and performance tools cost extra (£2.15 per employee on Plus)

    3. Xero Payroll: best if you already use Xero

    Xero Payroll is recognised by HMRC and lives inside Xero. Grow (£39 a month) includes payroll for one person, Comprehensive (£55) for five and Ultimate (£70) for ten. Extra people cost £1.50 a month on Ignite, Grow and Comprehensive, and £1 a month on Ultimate (as of November 2026). On Ignite (£18) payroll is entirely charged at £1.50 per person. Higher plans also include a number of domestic bill and payroll payments made directly from Xero.

    Pros

    • Very cheap for a director’s salary or a couple of staff on an existing Xero plan
    • Payroll costs post straight into your accounts

    Cons

    • Makes little sense if you do not want Xero for accounting
    • Larger teams with complex pay may outgrow it

    4. QuickBooks Payroll: best for QuickBooks users

    QuickBooks Payroll is an add-on to QuickBooks Online Simple Start, Essentials, Plus or Advanced (not Sole Trader Plus). Payroll Core costs £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages. Core includes automatic tax, National Insurance and pension calculations, automatic FPS filing, auto-enrolment, pension submissions to NEST, payslips and an employee portal, and it supports weekly, two-weekly, four-weekly and monthly pay. Payroll Premium is £10 a month plus £2 per active employee and Payroll Elite is £15 a month plus £3 per active employee (as of November 2026, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages from 15 June 2026). Those tiers include QuickBooks Time for time tracking and scheduling.

    One thing to watch: since 15 June 2026, QuickBooks bills for every employee marked Active at the start of your billing month, whether or not you paid them. Mark leavers and seasonal staff as “Not on payroll” to avoid paying for them.

    Pros

    • Low cost for small teams
    • Flexible pay frequencies and automatic NEST submissions

    Cons

    • Requires a paid QuickBooks Online plan as well
    • Easy to overpay if employee statuses are not kept up to date

    5. FreeAgent: best for directors of one-person companies

    If you run a one-person limited company and pay yourself a small salary, FreeAgent’s included payroll is hard to beat. It runs monthly payroll and files PAYE and National Insurance to HMRC, and it is free if you bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle. Otherwise the limited company plan is £33 a month ex VAT. FreeAgent has no public affiliate programme.

    Pros

    • Payroll included with the accounting subscription
    • Free with qualifying business bank accounts

    Cons

    • Monthly payroll only, so not ideal for weekly-paid staff
    • Built for very small businesses rather than growing teams

    6. Moneysoft Payroll Manager: best budget desktop option

    Moneysoft Payroll Manager is a long-established UK desktop product that is popular with bookkeepers. Annual licences include all updates and email support: £95 a year ex VAT for one employer with up to 20 employees, £190 ex VAT for multiple payrolls of up to 100 employees each, and £285 ex VAT for up to 250 (as of November 2026). It runs on Windows 11 only. Moneysoft says Payroll Manager will not work on Windows 10 after the end of April 2026, and it is not designed for Mac. Moneysoft has no public affiliate programme.

    Pros

    • Very low annual cost
    • Handles multiple payrolls on the higher licences, useful for bookkeepers

    Cons

    • Desktop software rather than cloud
    • Less polished than cloud rivals, with no built-in accounting

    7. HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: best free option

    Basic PAYE Tools is free software from HMRC for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC, and runs on Windows, macOS and Ubuntu Linux. You must be registered as an employer and have a PAYE Online login first. HMRC says it has limitations and is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. It does produce payslips: HMRC’s user guide (updated 21 July 2026) explains how to open an employee’s payment record, choose Payslip, save it as a PDF, and print it or email it once the employee has agreed. It does not support auto-enrolment or calculate workplace pension contributions, so you would need another way to meet those duties.

    Pros

    • Completely free, from HMRC
    • Fine for a director-only payroll or one or two staff

    Cons

    • Limited to fewer than 10 employees
    • Basic features and a desktop interface; no auto-enrolment or automatic pension submissions

    Other free payroll software on HMRC’s list

    HMRC’s list also includes these free products for businesses with fewer than 10 employees (15 November 2026): Primo Payroll, AI Payroll and Flow Payroll (Accentra Technologies), FreePayroll (Collegia Partners), Enrolpay Small Payroll, RTI Lite (Hartigan Software Design), 1 A Simple Payroll and Stansoft Linux. Check each one’s features against the list above before you rely on it.

    Switching payroll software mid-year

    You can change payroll software at any point. HMRC warns that some software will not let you keep the same employee Payroll IDs. If yours does not, put “Yes” in the “Payroll ID changed indicator” for each employee in your next Full Payment Submission, or your PAYE bill may be calculated incorrectly and records duplicated (GOV.UK).

    Frequently asked questions

    Is there free payroll software recognised by HMRC?

    Yes. HMRC’s recognised list includes free software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees, including HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools, FreePayroll, Enrolpay Small Payroll, RTI Lite and 1 A Simple Payroll. Free tools are often more limited: Basic PAYE Tools can create payslips, but it does not handle auto-enrolment or pension submissions.

    Do I need payroll software if I am the only director?

    Usually, if you pay yourself a salary through PAYE. You must report it to HMRC in real time using payroll software. FreeAgent, Xero, Sage and Kashflow include payroll that suits a single director, and Basic PAYE Tools is free.

    Can I use my accounting software for payroll?

    Often. Sage Accounting, Xero, FreeAgent and IRIS Kashflow include payroll in some or all plans, and QuickBooks offers it as a paid add-on. Zoho Books and FreshBooks did not have an HMRC-recognised UK payroll product on HMRC’s list on 15 November 2026.

    What is the cheapest payroll software for a small business?

    HMRC’s Basic PAYE Tools is free for fewer than 10 employees. Among paid products, QuickBooks Payroll Core (£5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, on top of QuickBooks) and Moneysoft Payroll Manager (£95 a year for up to 20 employees) are among the lowest-cost options we checked.

    Does HMRC recommend any payroll software?

    No. HMRC publishes a list of recognised software but says it cannot recommend one product over another and is not responsible for problems with software you buy.

    About the author

    The BooksCompass team researches UK accounting, payroll and bookkeeping software for sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. We check prices and features against vendor pages and HMRC guidance on GOV.UK, and we say when something has not been tested hands-on. How we choose · hello@bookscompass.co.uk

  • Best accounting software for UK small businesses (2026)

    Updated 18 November 2026 · By The BooksCompass team · Prices and features checked 18 November 2026

    Ad – This comparison contains affiliate links marked [£]. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our rankings, and we include software that pays us nothing. How we make money

    Choosing accounting software used to be a matter of taste. Since 6 April 2026 it has become a compliance decision for many sole traders and landlords, because Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax now requires HMRC-recognised software for anyone whose qualifying income was over £50,000 in 2024 to 2025. The threshold falls to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028 (GOV.UK).

    This guide compares seven products UK small businesses actually use. Every price below was checked on the vendor’s UK website on 18 November 2026 and excludes VAT unless we say otherwise. Introductory discounts change often, so we quote the regular monthly price and mention the offer separately.

    Our picks at a glance

    Best overall: Xero

    Clean, well-supported cloud accounting that scales from a one-person company to a team with payroll. MTD for Income Tax ready and recognised on HMRC’s software finder.

    Best for sole traders who want a low entry price: QuickBooks Online

    The Sole Trader Plus plan is built around Self Assessment and MTD for Income Tax, with a 30-day free trial.

    Best for VAT-registered businesses that need payroll included: Sage Accounting

    Every Sage Accounting plan includes payroll for at least one employee, and there is a free plan for non-VAT-registered sole traders.

    Best for freelancers and contractors: FreeAgent

    Excellent tax timeline and Self Assessment tools, and free if you bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle. We earn nothing from FreeAgent.

    Best free option: Zoho Books

    A genuinely usable free plan that HMRC lists for MTD for Income Tax, with paid tiers from £12 a month.

    Comparison table

    ProductStarting price (ex VAT/month)Free trial or offerEmployees/users includedMTD-readyHMRC-recognisedBest for
    XeroIgnite £18; then Grow £39, Comprehensive £55, Ultimate £70 (as of November 2026)90% off for 6 months for new customers, or one month freeUsers not charged per seat; payroll 0 on Ignite, 1 / 5 / 10 people on Grow / Comprehensive / UltimateYes — MTD for VAT on every plan; MTD for Income Tax ready on every planYes — on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026)Growing small businesses and limited companies
    QuickBooks OnlineFrom £10 (sole-trader plans) and from £16.60 (limited-company plans) as of November 2026. See Intuit’s UK pricing page for current Essentials, Plus and Advanced regular prices.30-day free trial, or a discount instead of the trial1 user on Sole Trader Plus and Simple Start; 3 / 5 / 25 users on Essentials / Plus / Advanced. Payroll is a paid add-on (Core £5 + £1.50 per active employee).Yes — MTD for Income Tax on all plans; VAT submission from Simple Start (not Sole Trader Plus)Yes — on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026)Sole traders and landlords; businesses with apps to connect
    Sage AccountingSole Trader Free £0; Sole Trader £7; Start £20; Standard £43; Plus £59 (as of November 2026)Free Sole Trader plan (no time limit); 90% off for 10 months on Start, Standard and Plus1 user on Start, 3 on Standard, unlimited on Plus. Payroll: 1 employee on Start and Standard, 5 on Plus, then £1.85 per employee.Yes — Sole Trader plans for MTD for Income Tax (not VAT); Accounting Start and above for VATYes — on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026)VAT-registered micro businesses with staff; non-VAT sole traders on the free plan
    FreeAgentSole trader £19; limited company £33; partnership or LLP £27; unincorporated landlord £10 (as of November 2026)30-day free trial; 50% off for the first 6 months (or first year if billed annually); free with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or qualifying Mettle usePayroll included (monthly). Not sold per user in the way QuickBooks is.Yes — MTD for VAT and MTD for Income Tax (vendor and previously confirmed on HMRC’s finder)Yes — on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026) and on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Freelancers, contractors and one-person companies
    Zoho BooksFree £0; paid plans from Standard £12 a month (£10 billed annually). Professional £24 (£20); Premium £30 (£25). Prices exclusive of local taxes (as of November 2026).14-day free trial of paid featuresFree plan: 1 user + 1 accountant, and 1,000 invoices / 1,000 expenses a year. No turnover limit is stated.Yes — MTD for VAT and MTD for Income Tax from the free plan (vendor)Yes — on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026). No Zoho product on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (12 November 2026).Best free option for sole traders and landlords
    FreshBooksLite £16; Plus £30; Premium £42 (as of November 2026). Treated as ex VAT: FreshBooks’ terms add VAT on top of quoted prices.30-day free trial (no credit card); 50% off for 3 months for new customersLite: 5 clients. Extra team members £8 per user a month. Premium includes 2 team members.MTD for VAT on Plus and Premium (vendor). Not a complete MTD for Income Tax answer on its own.Not on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder when last checked on 15 November 2026. No FreshBooks product on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (12 November 2026).Invoicing-heavy service businesses that are not joining MTD for Income Tax
    IRIS KashflowStarter £13.50; Business £27.50 (as of November 2026). Prices exclusive of VAT per KashFlow’s terms.14-day free trial; 90% off for 6 months for new customersStarter: 1 user, 10 invoices and 25 bank transactions a month. Both plans include payroll for up to 5 employees.Yes — MTD for VAT on both plans. HMRC’s finder listed IRIS Kashflow for self-employment income only (15 November 2026).IRIS Kashflow listed for self-employment income on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder (checked 15 November 2026). Landlords should look elsewhere.Budget UK accounting with payroll included
    CrunchCrunch Plus software-only £10 + VAT a month (as of November 2026). Full-service accountancy is quote-based by transaction volume.14-day free trial (stated on the software pricing page)Not published as a simple user cap on the software-only page we checked.Vendor says HMRC recognised and MTD for Income Tax compatible. Interactive HMRC finder not re-run on 18 November 2026.Vendor claim of HMRC recognition. Not re-confirmed on HMRC’s interactive MTD for Income Tax finder on 18 November 2026.Software-only bookkeeping with optional accountant support

    Prices are the vendors’ regular monthly prices for new customers on 15 November 2026. “On HMRC’s finder” means the product appeared in HMRC’s Find software that works with Making Tax Digital for Income Tax tool on that date.

    How we chose

    We started from what UK small businesses must do by law, then looked at cost and day-to-day usability:

    • Compliance first. Is the product on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder? Can it file MTD VAT returns? Is its payroll on HMRC’s recognised payroll list?
    • Real cost. The regular price after any introductory offer, plus the add-ons a typical small business ends up paying for (payroll, extra users, receipt capture).
    • Fit for UK businesses. CIS for construction, UK bank feeds, UK-based support and UK tax years.
    • Honesty about what we have not done. These assessments are based on vendor documentation, pricing pages and HMRC lists. We say when we have tested something hands-on, and we include software that pays us nothing.

    Commission never decides a ranking. Read our full how we choose method.

    1. Xero: best overall

    Xero is the product we would point most UK small businesses towards first, particularly limited companies and anyone who expects to take on staff. It is HMRC-recognised for MTD for Income Tax and for VAT, every plan can submit VAT returns, and its add-on marketplace is the broadest in the UK market alongside QuickBooks.

    Plans (ex VAT, regular price): Ignite £18, Grow £39, Comprehensive £55 and Ultimate £70 a month. New customers can currently take 90% off for the first six months or one month free. Ignite is limited to 20 invoices and 10 bills a month, and charges £1.50 per person for payroll. Grow includes payroll for one person, Comprehensive for five and Ultimate for ten, with £1.50 per additional person. Company accounts and Corporation Tax filing is an optional £120 a year.

    Pros

    • Recognised by HMRC for MTD for Income Tax, MTD for VAT and payroll
    • Every plan includes VAT returns, CIS calculations and bank reconciliation
    • Payroll built in, so a director’s salary or a first employee needs no extra product
    • Huge range of integrations and plenty of UK accountants who know it well

    Cons

    • Ignite’s 20-invoice and 10-bill limits will pinch a busy sole trader quickly
    • Multi-currency starts at Comprehensive (£55)
    • The jump from Ignite to Grow more than doubles the price

    2. QuickBooks Online: best for sole traders who want a low entry price

    QuickBooks Online has a plan designed around the sole trader’s year: Sole Trader Plus covers bank feeds, income and expenses, CIS, mileage and receipt capture, and is listed as MTD for Income Tax ready. It cannot submit VAT returns; that starts on Simple Start. Essentials (3 users), Plus (5 users, projects and inventory) and Advanced (25 users) follow. All plans come with a 30-day free trial, although taking a discount means giving up the trial.

    Price (as of November 2026): On its Making Tax Digital software page, Intuit states sole-trader plans start at £10 a month ex VAT and limited-company plans start at £16.60 a month ex VAT. Payroll is a paid add-on available from Simple Start upwards; Intuit’s own help pages confirm Payroll Core at £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee. For current regular prices of Essentials, Plus and Advanced, see Intuit’s UK pricing page (https://quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing/).

    Pros

    • A dedicated low-cost plan for sole traders and landlords, listed on HMRC’s MTD finder
    • Strong mobile app with mileage tracking and receipt capture
    • Payroll Core is cheap for very small teams and handles auto-enrolment submissions to NEST
    • Widely supported by UK accountants and bookkeepers

    Cons

    • No VAT submission on Sole Trader Plus, so VAT-registered sole traders need Simple Start
    • Payroll always costs extra, and from June 2026 is billed on every employee marked Active
    • User caps are hard: a second user means moving up to Essentials

    3. Sage Accounting: best for VAT-registered businesses that need payroll included

    Sage is the UK’s home-grown option and its cloud product now bundles payroll into every business plan. Start (£20 a month, 1 user) is aimed at VAT-registered sole traders and micro businesses; Standard (£43, 3 users) adds supplier management, CIS and receipt capture; Plus (£59, unlimited users) adds inventory, budgets and multi-currency. All prices exclude VAT and new customers currently get 90% off for ten months.

    For non-VAT-registered sole traders and landlords, Sage also offers Sole Trader Free (£0) and Sole Trader (£7 a month), both of which appear on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder as “Sage Sole Trader & Landlord”.

    Pros

    • Payroll included: one employee on Start and Standard, five on Plus, then £1.85 per employee a month
    • Free MTD for Income Tax plan for simple sole traders and landlords
    • UK-based support and a long track record with UK accountants
    • Integrated CIS: Start covers CIS if you are a subcontractor only; contractor CIS, including monthly CIS300 returns, needs Standard or Plus

    Cons

    • The Sole Trader Free plan is limited (for example, five sales invoices a month)
    • Start is single-user; more users means Standard at more than double the price
    • Receipt capture beyond the included allowance costs £0.20 per document

    4. FreeAgent: best for freelancers and contractors

    FreeAgent is built for the self-employed and small limited companies, and it shows. Its tax timeline tells you what you owe and when, it files Self Assessment and VAT returns, and limited company users can prepare final accounts and Corporation Tax data. Monthly payroll for directors and employees is included and is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list.

    Price (ex VAT, regular): sole traders £19 a month, limited companies £33, partnerships and LLPs £27, unincorporated landlords £10. There is a 30-day free trial and currently 50% off for six months, or a discounted first year if you pay annually. The headline feature: FreeAgent is free for as long as you keep a business current account with NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland or Ulster Bank, or use Mettle and make at least one transaction a month.

    FreeAgent does not run a public affiliate programme, so we earn nothing if you choose it. It is here because it is often the right answer.

    Pros

    • Free with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle
    • Excellent Self Assessment and tax-estimate tools; on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder
    • Payroll included at no extra cost
    • UK-based support

    Cons

    • Less suited to businesses with stock or complex multi-user needs
    • Smart Capture is limited to 10 receipts and bills a month unless you pay £5 a month
    • Fewer third-party integrations than Xero or QuickBooks

    5. Zoho Books: best free option

    Zoho Books’ UK free plan is unusually complete: invoices, quotes, expenses, bank reconciliation, MTD VAT filing, CIS tracking and, newly, MTD for Income Tax quarterly updates and Self Assessment (SA100) filing for sole traders and landlords. It is one user plus your accountant. HMRC’s finder lists Zoho for self-employment, UK property and foreign property income.

    Price (as of November 2026, exclusive of local taxes): Free £0; Standard £12 a month (£10 billed annually); Professional £24 (£20); Premium £30 (£25), per organisation. Zoho’s UK site states that prices are exclusive of local taxes, so VAT is added at the UK rate. The free plan has no turnover or revenue limit stated on Zoho’s pricing pages; it is limited to 1,000 invoices and 1,000 expenses a year, and to one user plus one accountant.

    Pros

    • Free plan covers MTD for Income Tax, MTD VAT and Self Assessment filing
    • Handles foreign property income, which some rivals do not
    • Paid plans are good value for small teams (3 users on Standard, 5 on Professional)

    Cons

    • No HMRC-recognised Zoho payroll product appeared on HMRC’s list on 15 November 2026
    • Fewer UK accountants use it day to day
    • Bank feeds across multiple accounts start on the Standard plan

    6. FreshBooks: best for invoicing-heavy service businesses

    FreshBooks is polished invoicing and expenses software with time tracking, which suits designers, consultants and agencies who bill by the hour. It can submit MTD VAT returns. However, it did not appear on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder on 15 November 2026, so it is not suitable on its own if you are a sole trader or landlord already in MTD for Income Tax, or joining in April 2027.

    Price (as of November 2026): Lite £16, Plus £30 and Premium £42 a month, with 50% off for three months for new customers. Lite is limited to five clients; extra team members cost £8 per user a month. FreshBooks’ Terms of Service say quoted prices are before applicable taxes, including value-added tax, which are added on top and itemised separately, so we treat these GBP prices as excluding VAT.

    Pros

    • Excellent invoicing, proposals and time tracking
    • Easy to learn

    Cons

    • Not on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder at the time of writing
    • No HMRC-recognised FreshBooks payroll
    • Client limits on the cheaper plans

    7. IRIS Kashflow: best budget option with payroll

    Kashflow, now owned by IRIS, is a UK-only product with straightforward pricing. Starter (£13.50 a month) allows 10 invoices and 25 bank transactions a month for one user; Business (£27.50) removes those limits and adds multiple users. Both include payroll for up to five employees and MTD VAT submission. New customers currently get 90% off for six months. HMRC’s finder lists IRIS Kashflow for self-employment income only, so landlords should look elsewhere.

    Pros

    • Payroll for up to five employees included
    • Simple, UK-focused product with predictable pricing

    Cons

    • Starter’s transaction limits are tight
    • Not listed for property income under MTD for Income Tax
    • Smaller ecosystem than Xero, QuickBooks or Sage

    Also worth a look

    • Coconut, Clear Books and Pandle all have free versions on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax finder and are worth a look for very simple sole trader books.
    • Crunch combines software with an optional accountancy service for freelancers and limited companies. Software-only Crunch Plus is £10 + VAT a month (as of November 2026). Full-service accountancy packages are still quote-based by transaction volume, so we have not ranked Crunch in the table above.
    • Bridging software lets you keep spreadsheets and still file MTD quarterly updates. See our Making Tax Digital guide.

    How to choose

    1. Check if and when MTD for Income Tax applies to you. If you are a sole trader or landlord with qualifying income over £30,000 in 2025 to 2026, you start on 6 April 2027. Choose software that is on HMRC’s finder and covers every income type you have (self-employment, UK property, foreign property).
    2. Are you VAT-registered? You must already use MTD-compatible software for VAT. QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus and Sage’s Sole Trader plans cannot file VAT returns.
    3. Will you run payroll? Sage, Xero, FreeAgent and Kashflow include some payroll. QuickBooks charges for it. If payroll is your main need, see our best payroll software guide.
    4. Work out the price after the offer ends. A 90% discount for six months is welcome, but budget for month seven.
    5. Ask your accountant. If you use one, software they already support will save you both time and fees.

    Still torn between the big three? Read QuickBooks vs Xero vs Sage.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the best accounting software for a UK sole trader?

    For most sole traders, QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus, Sage’s Sole Trader plans, FreeAgent and Zoho Books are the strongest fits, because all four are listed on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder. FreeAgent is free if you bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle, and Sage and Zoho both have free plans.

    Do I need accounting software for Making Tax Digital?

    If MTD for Income Tax applies to you, yes: you must keep digital records and send quarterly updates using HMRC-recognised software. It applies from 6 April 2026 if your qualifying income was over £50,000 in 2024 to 2025, from April 2027 above £30,000 and from April 2028 above £20,000. If you prefer spreadsheets, bridging software can connect them to HMRC.

    Is there free accounting software that works with MTD?

    Yes. On 15 November 2026 HMRC’s software finder listed free versions including Zoho Books, Sage Sole Trader & Landlord Free, Clear Books Free, Coconut Free, Pandle and FreeAgent (free with NatWest, RBS or Mettle). Check each free plan’s limits before committing.

    Are the prices in this guide inclusive of VAT?

    No. UK business software is usually priced excluding VAT at 20%. Unless we say otherwise, all prices here are the vendor’s regular monthly price excluding VAT, checked on 18 November 2026.

    Does BooksCompass earn money from these recommendations?

    Sometimes. Some links are affiliate links marked [£], and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We also recommend software that pays us nothing, such as FreeAgent, and commission never decides our rankings. See how we make money.

    About the author

    The BooksCompass team researches UK accounting, payroll and bookkeeping software for sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. We check prices and features against vendor pages and HMRC guidance on GOV.UK, and we say when something has not been tested hands-on. How we choose · hello@bookscompass.co.uk