Best payroll software for UK small businesses (2026)

Written by

in

Updated 18 November 2026 · By The BooksCompass team · Prices and features checked 18 November 2026

Ad – This comparison contains affiliate links marked [£]. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our rankings, and we include software that pays us nothing. How we make money

If you employ anyone in the UK, including paying yourself a salary as a company director, you need payroll software that reports PAYE to HMRC in real time, unless you are exempt (GOV.UK). The sensible starting point is HMRC’s own list of recognised payroll software, which was last updated on 12 November 2026 (GOV.UK). Every product in this guide is on that list.

HMRC is careful to say it cannot recommend one product over another. We can, so below we narrow a list of around 150 suppliers down to the handful that make most sense for sole-trader employers, small limited companies and micro businesses. Prices were checked on vendors’ UK pages on 18 November 2026 and exclude VAT unless stated.

Our picks at a glance

Best dedicated payroll for small employers: BrightPay

Specialist payroll software with per-employee pricing and every feature included. We earn nothing from BrightPay.

Best accounting and payroll in one: Sage Accounting

Payroll for one employee is included in every Sage Accounting business plan (five on Plus), then £1.85 per employee a month.

Best if you already use Xero: Xero Payroll

Built into Xero’s Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate plans, or £1.50 per person on Ignite.

Best free option for under 10 employees: HMRC Basic PAYE Tools

Free from HMRC itself, with no subscription. Basic, but it does the legal minimum.

Comparison table

ProductStarting price (ex VAT/month)Free trialEmployees/users includedMTD-readyHMRC-recognisedBest for
BrightPay CloudFrom £8.25 a month ex VAT (1 employer, up to 3 employees; as of November 2026), or £84 a year (£7/month billed annually). Then banded per employee; extra employers add a flat fee. Annual billing is discounted. Use Bright’s calculator for other counts.Yes — free trial, full access (vendor)Base monthly price covers 1 employer with up to 3 employees; then per-employee bands. Starters and leavers counted. Up to 300 employees per employer (vendor).Yes — RTI (FPS) and auto-enrolment; CIS via BrightCISYes — BrightPay is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Specialist payroll for small employers, bookkeepers and bureaus
Sage Accounting (payroll included)From £20 a month for Start (as of November 2026), which includes payroll for 1 employee; Standard £43 (1 included); Plus £59 (5 included); then £1.85 per extra employee90% off for 10 months on Start, Standard and Plus; Sole Trader plans are not the payroll business plans1 employee on Start and Standard; 5 on PlusYes — RTI / PAYE and National Insurance calculations, employee payslips and salary payments (vendor)Yes — Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)VAT-registered businesses that want accounting and payroll in one subscription
Sage Payroll (standalone)From £12 a month (Payroll Essentials) as of November 2026; Standard and Premium also offered. Extra employees from £2.40 / £4.40 / £6.40 a month respectively, with volume discounts, up to 150 employees. 90% off for 10 months is currently advertised (then the regular price).Promotional 90% off for 10 months (vendor). Cancel-anytime rolling subscription.5 employees included on every planYes — RTI submissions, auto-enrolment / workplace pensions, payslips (vendor)Yes — Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Standalone cloud payroll and HR for businesses that do not want Sage Accounting
Xero PayrollIgnite £18 + £1.50 per person; or included in Grow £39 (1 person), Comprehensive £55 (5), Ultimate £70 (10). Extra people £1.50 a month, or £1 on Ultimate (as of November 2026).90% off for 6 months for new customers, or one month free (base Xero plan)1 / 5 / 10 people included on Grow / Comprehensive / Ultimate; none included on IgniteYes — payroll inside Xero with RTI (vendor)Yes — Xero Payroll is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Existing Xero users and businesses already choosing Xero for accounting
QuickBooks PayrollAdd-on to QuickBooks Online (Simple Start and above, not Sole Trader Plus). Core: £5 a month + £1.50 per active employee. Premium: £10 + £2. Elite: £15 + £3. Plus a QuickBooks plan (limited-company plans from £16.60 a month as of November 2026).30-day free trial on QuickBooks Online (or a discount instead of the trial)No employees included in the Core base fee; you pay per employee marked Active at the start of the billing monthYes — automatic FPS filing, auto-enrolment and NEST submissions on Core (vendor)Yes — QuickBooks is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)QuickBooks users; weekly or four-weekly pay
FreeAgentIncluded with the accounting plan: from £19 a month (sole trader) or £33 (limited company), or free with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or qualifying Mettle use (as of November 2026)30-day free trial; 50% off for the first 6 months (or first year if annual)Payroll included; FreeAgent says you can pay as many employees as you need. Monthly payroll only.Yes — files PAYE and National Insurance to HMRC (vendor)Yes — FreeAgent is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026) and on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder (checked 15 November 2026)Directors of one-person companies and very small teams paid monthly
Moneysoft Payroll Manager£95 a year ex VAT for 1 employer with up to 20 employees (about £7.92 a month). £190 a year ex VAT for multiple employers, up to 100 employees each; £285 a year ex VAT for up to 250 (as of November 2026).Not stated on the pricing pagePayroll Manager 20: 1 employer, up to 20 employees including leavers in the tax yearYes — RTI filing online (vendor; internet required)Yes — Moneysoft Payroll Manager is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list (updated 12 November 2026)Bookkeepers and cost-conscious employers happy with Windows 11 desktop software
HMRC Basic PAYE ToolsFreeNot applicable — free download from GOV.UKFewer than 10 employeesRTI (FPS and EPS) yes. Can create payslips (save as PDF). Does not support auto-enrolment or calculate pension contributions.Yes — listed under free payroll software on HMRC’s recognised list (updated 12 November 2026)Employers with fewer than 10 staff who can handle pensions separately

What your payroll software must do

Before comparing features, it helps to be clear on the legal basics. As an employer you must register with HMRC, report pay and deductions to HMRC on or before each payday in a Full Payment Submission (FPS), produce payslips for each employee, and send an Employer Payment Summary (EPS) in any tax month when you paid nobody (GOV.UK: running payroll). You also have workplace pension (auto-enrolment) duties for eligible staff.

GOV.UK suggests checking whether software can:

  • produce payslips
  • record pension deductions and make pension payments
  • pay different people over different periods (for example weekly and monthly)
  • send an Employer Payment Summary (EPS) or Earlier Year Update (EYU)

Not every recognised product does all of these, especially the free ones.

How we chose

We only considered products on HMRC’s recognised list on 15 November 2026. From there we favoured software that a business with roughly 1 to 25 employees can set up without an accountant, that handles auto-enrolment, and that has transparent UK pricing. We have not run payroll in every product ourselves; our assessments are based on vendor documentation, pricing pages and HMRC’s lists. See how we choose.

1. BrightPay: best dedicated payroll for small employers

BrightPay, from Bright Software Group, is one of the most popular specialist payroll products among UK accountants and bureaus, and it works just as well for a single employer. It is on HMRC’s recognised payroll list. It handles RTI submissions, auto-enrolment, statutory payments and employee self-service. From the 2026/27 tax year BrightPay is cloud-only: Bright’s UK pricing FAQ says the desktop version no longer receives updates, support or legislative compliance.

Price: BrightPay Cloud prices per employee, banded by your highest recorded number of employers and employees, with monthly or annual billing and every feature included. Annual billing is discounted. There is a free trial. As of November 2026, Bright’s official UK calculator starts at £8.25 a month ex VAT for one employer with up to three employees, or £84 a year ex VAT (£7.00 a month when billed annually). From four employees, a per-employee rate applies and falls as the headcount band rises; extra employers add a flat fee. Use Bright’s pricing calculator (https://brightsg.com/brightpay-cloud-payroll-software/#pricing) for your own counts.

BrightPay has no public affiliate programme, so we earn nothing if you choose it.

Pros

  • Payroll specialist with full auto-enrolment and employee self-service
  • Every feature included in per-employee pricing
  • Widely supported by UK accountants

Cons

  • Separate from your accounting software, so you will need an integration or journal export
  • Pricing is banded, so the monthly bill rises with your highest recorded employer and employee counts

2. Sage Accounting: best accounting and payroll in one

Sage Business Cloud Payroll is on HMRC’s list, and Sage now includes payroll in every Sage Accounting business plan: one employee on Start (£20 a month) and Standard (£43), five on Plus (£59), then £1.85 per employee a month. It covers RTI, automatic tax and National Insurance calculations, employee self-service payslips, leave management and salary payments, and Sage Copilot flags pay that looks unusual. Sage 50 Payroll, the desktop product, is also on HMRC’s list for larger or more traditional set-ups.

Pros

  • No separate payroll subscription for very small teams
  • Payroll and accounting in one place, so journals post automatically
  • UK-based support

Cons

  • Per-employee charges add up beyond a handful of staff
  • Shift scheduling and performance tools cost extra (£2.15 per employee on Plus)

3. Xero Payroll: best if you already use Xero

Xero Payroll is recognised by HMRC and lives inside Xero. Grow (£39 a month) includes payroll for one person, Comprehensive (£55) for five and Ultimate (£70) for ten. Extra people cost £1.50 a month on Ignite, Grow and Comprehensive, and £1 a month on Ultimate (as of November 2026). On Ignite (£18) payroll is entirely charged at £1.50 per person. Higher plans also include a number of domestic bill and payroll payments made directly from Xero.

Pros

  • Very cheap for a director’s salary or a couple of staff on an existing Xero plan
  • Payroll costs post straight into your accounts

Cons

  • Makes little sense if you do not want Xero for accounting
  • Larger teams with complex pay may outgrow it

4. QuickBooks Payroll: best for QuickBooks users

QuickBooks Payroll is an add-on to QuickBooks Online Simple Start, Essentials, Plus or Advanced (not Sole Trader Plus). Payroll Core costs £5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages. Core includes automatic tax, National Insurance and pension calculations, automatic FPS filing, auto-enrolment, pension submissions to NEST, payslips and an employee portal, and it supports weekly, two-weekly, four-weekly and monthly pay. Payroll Premium is £10 a month plus £2 per active employee and Payroll Elite is £15 a month plus £3 per active employee (as of November 2026, confirmed on Intuit’s UK help pages from 15 June 2026). Those tiers include QuickBooks Time for time tracking and scheduling.

One thing to watch: since 15 June 2026, QuickBooks bills for every employee marked Active at the start of your billing month, whether or not you paid them. Mark leavers and seasonal staff as “Not on payroll” to avoid paying for them.

Pros

  • Low cost for small teams
  • Flexible pay frequencies and automatic NEST submissions

Cons

  • Requires a paid QuickBooks Online plan as well
  • Easy to overpay if employee statuses are not kept up to date

5. FreeAgent: best for directors of one-person companies

If you run a one-person limited company and pay yourself a small salary, FreeAgent’s included payroll is hard to beat. It runs monthly payroll and files PAYE and National Insurance to HMRC, and it is free if you bank with NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle. Otherwise the limited company plan is £33 a month ex VAT. FreeAgent has no public affiliate programme.

Pros

  • Payroll included with the accounting subscription
  • Free with qualifying business bank accounts

Cons

  • Monthly payroll only, so not ideal for weekly-paid staff
  • Built for very small businesses rather than growing teams

6. Moneysoft Payroll Manager: best budget desktop option

Moneysoft Payroll Manager is a long-established UK desktop product that is popular with bookkeepers. Annual licences include all updates and email support: £95 a year ex VAT for one employer with up to 20 employees, £190 ex VAT for multiple payrolls of up to 100 employees each, and £285 ex VAT for up to 250 (as of November 2026). It runs on Windows 11 only. Moneysoft says Payroll Manager will not work on Windows 10 after the end of April 2026, and it is not designed for Mac. Moneysoft has no public affiliate programme.

Pros

  • Very low annual cost
  • Handles multiple payrolls on the higher licences, useful for bookkeepers

Cons

  • Desktop software rather than cloud
  • Less polished than cloud rivals, with no built-in accounting

7. HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: best free option

Basic PAYE Tools is free software from HMRC for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC, and runs on Windows, macOS and Ubuntu Linux. You must be registered as an employer and have a PAYE Online login first. HMRC says it has limitations and is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. It does produce payslips: HMRC’s user guide (updated 21 July 2026) explains how to open an employee’s payment record, choose Payslip, save it as a PDF, and print it or email it once the employee has agreed. It does not support auto-enrolment or calculate workplace pension contributions, so you would need another way to meet those duties.

Pros

  • Completely free, from HMRC
  • Fine for a director-only payroll or one or two staff

Cons

  • Limited to fewer than 10 employees
  • Basic features and a desktop interface; no auto-enrolment or automatic pension submissions

Other free payroll software on HMRC’s list

HMRC’s list also includes these free products for businesses with fewer than 10 employees (15 November 2026): Primo Payroll, AI Payroll and Flow Payroll (Accentra Technologies), FreePayroll (Collegia Partners), Enrolpay Small Payroll, RTI Lite (Hartigan Software Design), 1 A Simple Payroll and Stansoft Linux. Check each one’s features against the list above before you rely on it.

Switching payroll software mid-year

You can change payroll software at any point. HMRC warns that some software will not let you keep the same employee Payroll IDs. If yours does not, put “Yes” in the “Payroll ID changed indicator” for each employee in your next Full Payment Submission, or your PAYE bill may be calculated incorrectly and records duplicated (GOV.UK).

Frequently asked questions

Is there free payroll software recognised by HMRC?

Yes. HMRC’s recognised list includes free software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees, including HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools, FreePayroll, Enrolpay Small Payroll, RTI Lite and 1 A Simple Payroll. Free tools are often more limited: Basic PAYE Tools can create payslips, but it does not handle auto-enrolment or pension submissions.

Do I need payroll software if I am the only director?

Usually, if you pay yourself a salary through PAYE. You must report it to HMRC in real time using payroll software. FreeAgent, Xero, Sage and Kashflow include payroll that suits a single director, and Basic PAYE Tools is free.

Can I use my accounting software for payroll?

Often. Sage Accounting, Xero, FreeAgent and IRIS Kashflow include payroll in some or all plans, and QuickBooks offers it as a paid add-on. Zoho Books and FreshBooks did not have an HMRC-recognised UK payroll product on HMRC’s list on 15 November 2026.

What is the cheapest payroll software for a small business?

HMRC’s Basic PAYE Tools is free for fewer than 10 employees. Among paid products, QuickBooks Payroll Core (£5 a month plus £1.50 per active employee, on top of QuickBooks) and Moneysoft Payroll Manager (£95 a year for up to 20 employees) are among the lowest-cost options we checked.

Does HMRC recommend any payroll software?

No. HMRC publishes a list of recognised software but says it cannot recommend one product over another and is not responsible for problems with software you buy.

About the author

The BooksCompass team researches UK accounting, payroll and bookkeeping software for sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. We check prices and features against vendor pages and HMRC guidance on GOV.UK, and we say when something has not been tested hands-on. How we choose · hello@bookscompass.co.uk